The 5 Mistakes That Kill a Story Before It Starts
You have the idea.
Maybe it’s been bouncing around in your head for weeks. Maybe a character showed up out of nowhere and refuses to leave. Maybe you can already see one particular scene so clearly that you’ve practically watched it play out in your head.
So you sit down to write.
The first few chapters fly.
You’re excited. The story feels alive. You’re already imagining the finished book sitting on a shelf.
And then…
Something happens.
The story slows down.
The characters start wandering around without much purpose.
You aren’t quite sure what should happen next.
Eventually, you find yourself staring at the manuscript wondering where all that initial excitement went.
Here’s the frustrating part:
The problem probably didn’t start where you got stuck.
It started much earlier.
Most stories don’t fall apart because the writer suddenly loses the ability to write. They fall apart because something essential was missing from the foundation.
Before you write 50,000 words only to discover the story isn’t working, let’s talk about five of the most common mistakes that can kill a story before it ever really gets started.
Mistakes That Kill a Story – Mistake #1: Starting With Plot Instead of Character
This one is easy to do.
You have a fantastic premise.
A woman witnesses a murder.
A soldier disappears during a classified mission.
A detective discovers the person she’s hunting knows something about her past.
Fantastic.
But that’s not a story yet.
It’s a situation.
The story begins when we know who is experiencing it and why it matters to them.
Readers don’t become emotionally invested in events.
They become invested in people.
Before worrying about everything that’s going to happen, spend some time figuring out who your story is happening to.
Ask:
- What does this character want?
- Why do they want it?
- What are they afraid of?
- What are they willing to risk?
- What would absolutely devastate them?
- What do they believe about themselves that may not actually be true?
Now your plot has something to push against.
A kidnapping is frightening.
A kidnapping involving the one person your fiercely independent heroine has finally allowed herself to love?
Now we have a problem.
Plot creates events.
Character gives those events meaning.
Mistakes That Kill a Story – Mistake #2: Building a World Without Building Conflict
Worldbuilding is fun.
Dangerously fun.
You can spend hours creating towns, organizations, histories, families, military units, political systems, maps, businesses, secret societies, or whatever your particular story requires.
And all of it can be useful.
But eventually, someone has to do something.
A fascinating world isn’t automatically a fascinating story.
Something needs to disrupt it.
Your protagonist needs to want something, and something needs to stand in the way.
Better yet, several somethings.
Conflict doesn’t necessarily mean explosions, gunfights, or screaming matches.
Conflict simply means there is something preventing your character from easily getting what they want.
It might be another person.
It might be circumstances.
It might be their own fear.
Usually, the strongest stories combine all three.
Build the world.
Make it interesting.
Give it texture and history and atmosphere.
Then ask the much more important question:
What can go wrong here?
And don’t be stingy.
Mistakes That Kill a Story – Mistake #3: Planning Forever
I love knowing where a story is going.
I like understanding my characters, identifying major turning points, seeing where the conflict is headed, and having enough of a roadmap that I don’t wander into Chapter 27 and suddenly wonder what on earth I’m doing there.
Planning is useful.
But planning can also become a very respectable-looking form of procrastination.
There’s always another character worksheet you could complete.
Another piece of research you could do.
Another plot point you could refine.
Another Pinterest board you could create.
Another outline you could reorganize.
At some point, you’re no longer preparing to write the book.
You’re avoiding writing the book.
And there is a hard truth every writer eventually has to accept:
You cannot plan your way to a finished manuscript.
Eventually, you have to write it.
You also won’t discover everything during the planning stage.
Some things only appear once the characters are moving through the story.
A conversation changes direction.
A character reacts differently than you expected.
A subplot suddenly connects to the main plot.
A better twist appears.
That’s part of writing.
Plan enough to give yourself direction.
Then get out of your own way and start telling the story.
Mistakes That Kill a Story – Mistake #4: Creating a Passive Protagonist
This is one of the fastest ways to drain the energy out of a story.
Things keep happening to the protagonist.
Someone threatens them.
Someone rescues them.
Someone gives them information.
Someone tells them where to go.
Someone solves the problem.
Meanwhile, your main character is basically being carried through their own book.
Readers want protagonists who make choices.
They don’t have to make the right choices.
In fact, sometimes terrible choices make spectacular stories.
But they need to do something.
A strong protagonist reacts to what’s happening and then makes a decision.
That decision creates consequences.
Those consequences create the next problem.
Now your character isn’t simply following the plot.
They’re helping create it.
This matters even when your protagonist is trapped in circumstances they can’t control.
They may not control what happens to them.
But they can control how they respond.
And those responses tell us who they are.
Give your characters agency.
Let them make decisions.
Let them screw things up.
Then make them deal with the consequences.
That’s where stories get interesting.
Mistakes That Kill a Story – Mistake #5: Ignoring the Stakes
Your protagonist wants something.
Great.
Now ask:
What happens if they don’t get it?
If the answer is essentially “not much,” you have a problem.
Readers need a reason to care whether your protagonist succeeds.
That’s where stakes come in.
And bigger doesn’t necessarily mean better.
You don’t have to threaten the entire world.
Sometimes one person’s heart is enough.
The important thing is that failure must cost something your character deeply values.
Their freedom.
Their career.
Their reputation.
Their family.
Their future.
Their identity.
Their chance at love.
Their life.
And ideally, the stakes aren’t only external.
Imagine a character trying to stop a dangerous criminal.
Those are external stakes.
Now imagine she’s also terrified that trusting her partner will make her vulnerable to the kind of loss she’s spent years avoiding.
Those are emotional stakes.
Combine them?
Now every dangerous decision carries two kinds of risk.
That’s when readers stop simply wondering what will happen.
They start caring what happens.
Mistakes That Kill a Story – Before You Write Chapter One…
You don’t need to know every scene.
You don’t need a perfect outline.
You don’t need biographies for every character who walks onto the page.
And you definitely don’t need to have the entire novel figured out before you begin.
But you do need a foundation.
Before starting your next story, make sure you understand:
- Who your story is really about
- What they want
- What’s preventing them from getting it
- What choices they’ll be forced to make
- What happens if they fail
Those five things will tell you more about the strength of your story than fifty pages of detailed outlining ever could.
Mistakes That Kill a Story – A Great Idea Is Only the Beginning
I love that first spark of a story.
There’s nothing quite like it.
For a little while, the possibilities are endless.
But an idea becomes a novel only when we give it something strong enough to stand on.
Characters give it heart.
Conflict gives it movement.
Decisions give it direction.
Consequences give it momentum.
Stakes give readers a reason to care.
Get those pieces working together, and suddenly you’re not dragging a story toward the finish line.
The story begins pulling you forward.
And that’s exactly what we want.
Because the goal isn’t simply to start another novel.
It’s to build one you’re excited enough to finish and your readers won’t want to put down.
Ready to Build Your Story?
If you’ve ever had a great idea but struggled to turn it into a complete novel, that’s exactly why I created the Story Builder System.
Instead of handing you a rigid formula and telling you exactly how your story should unfold, it helps you build the foundation underneath it: your characters, conflict, plot, Story Engine, and first-draft plan.
You’ll still have room to discover the unexpected.
You’ll just have a much better idea where you’re going.
Explore the Story Builder System →
The Story Builder System helps writers avoid these mistakes before they derail an entire manuscript.
LET’S CONNECT!
There are many ways to connect with Amy Stewart Bell. We would love to know what you think and any of the topics we offer. We welcome your comments and want to interact with you!
If you haven’t yet, grab your copies of Once Captured, Uncharted Captivity, and The Captive Mind.
You can also connect in other areas. Join us on Instagram @AmyWritesAll, on X @AmyWritesAll, and on Facebook @AmyWritesAll.
Be sure to join our community as well; you will get even more inside info!
